Claimed:[IMG]http://i59.tinypic.com/126a25g.png[/IMG]

[James 77]

[Mr. Grumpy Bear 347]

Effort: 2/2 - Text, lighting, blending, I'd say you have enough here.

Look: 2.5/3 - The text could use some help here and the lighting although good in placement is a little strong. Blending is good and as a whole this could be great with a little help.

Creativity: 1/1 - Sure


Total: 5.5/6

[Sandro 251]

Effort: 2/2 - Hmm... Okay, full marks.

 

Look: 2.25/3 - I feel like there are three major issues: 1) The sig overall feels too small and cramped, in part due to the overly large text (which acts as the focal point rather than the render). 2) The lack of colouring on the render. It's blended well, but I feel that there's a disconnect between the render and the background. 3) The entire graphic, most notably the render, looks a little blurry. It really could've used a sharpen filter IMO.

 

Creativity: 1/1

 

Overall: 5.25/6  ➨  FINAL GRADE: 5/6

 

P.S. I really debated what to grade this for a while, whether or not I should dock enough points to bring the final grade down to a 6. Overall this is a solid sig, but the fact it looks really blurry to me was just too much. That small addition would've made a world of differences IMO.

Edited March 2, 2014 by Sandro

[Guest]

Claimed