Look: 5.75/3 - I REALLY like this. For me 2 things would have set this over the top. 1. It looks a tad unfinished. Something over the render may have worked here. Even some smudging of the jersey to blend in the red with the grey background here would help imo depending on how its done. 2. In this case, I think the large canvas look hurts the sig a bit. Having these same elements in a slightly smaller sig would make this a lot better.
Text here is wicked.
Creativity: 1/1 - I'm actually very fond of your style. It's a nice clean way of making sigs. You're very underrated here. Keep at it!