S82 STEEL CAPTAINS

[Masu Chan 456]

[STZ 5,360]

Review:

 

Pretty attractive looking graphic. The effort level is there with the three jersey changes representing each captain. The renders all seem like different quatity, and that Hayes render looks like it might have been resized improperly. I think the text is cool and informative for the type of message you're delivering. The render strokes are good, but I think they should all match the same size of stroke. I still think a good level of effort was put into this, and I think that means a lot. 8/10

[ke1vi 662]

Review

 

This is pretty creative - I like how you have them stacked diagonally. It's also laid out pretty nice with the text at the top left. The logos are way too big on the jersey though but I assume you did that to cover up the existing. If you have Photoshop I would suggest trying to hide the existing logos with a soft brush or the clone stamp tool. I like the simple stripe background and it looks like you're getting familit with stroking objects like the render. Keep it up!

 

8/10

[badcolethetitan 921]

REVIEW:

I like this graphic, as well.. I am the captain on it. I think you did a fantastic job with keeping the graphic simple, but well organized. I like the fact that you ended up adding the logos on each of the players and also the "C" and "A". One suggestion is that if you are going to add the logo, trying to remove the logo behind it would be a fantastic idea by just painting over it and then using the blur tool. I also would in the future try to add some shadow to the text, as it could really make the text pop out at you. You could also add some shadows to the players, but you already have an outline which looks fantastic. Overall, I love the graphic and I think you did a great job!

Rating: 8/10