A Howl In The Night

[Subject056 1,198]

 

 

 

 

Edited September 14 by Subject056

[kirbithan 1,699]

Review: It's been a while since I've done a review, so here it goes! The first thing that sticks out to me is the great use of layers with the Vancouver logo in the background, which really makes the piece pop and catch the eye without drawing attention away from the renders, which I believe is a delicate balance that you pulled off perfectly! The jersey logo swap is clean and I love the little fabric texture that you added to give it that extra depth! I'm also always a sucker for VHL shield swaps, so overall, a super clean graphic that's simple yet so effective. If there's one small nitpick that I have, it's that I believe you could've erased the sponsor from the jersey so it doesn't distract from the Wolves logo as well as the sponsors on the helmets. Awesome job as always and as usual, I can't wait to see what you create next, Subject! Score: 9/10

[Steve 1,920]

Review:

You picked a couple of my favorite players so that is fun to see, though it doesn't effect my review, it's just a great choice. I like the frosted look to the logo and background in general. Not sure what is going on at the top of this graphic. I suspect some sort of blending issue. Overall, the background does it's job and compliments the main elements. Logo swaps look very good. I would have liked a total brand removal but it kind of looks more realistic with them intact. I think the only thing that I can see that might have been corrected is the black level. The black in the jersey is really crushed and lacking in detail. It's tricky to pull out detail and retain the level of black that is needed. Drew's beard also shows sign a higher black level. I can't fault you on that because it could simply be the original photo's issue. Overall I really like this. Simple and to the point.

9/10

[Mr Bohannan 114]

Review: Straight out off the start I have to say - Thank you! - for following the main basic thing when working with any type of graphic - High Quality Picture or Render!!! You can see the difference that it makes to the piece when you have chosen a really nice and crystal clear and sharp image to work with. No matter what you do to it, it will boost the overall look because of the quality of the original picture. Now moving on to the logo swap I would say that you have done quite an OK job when it comes to it. Is it ideal? No, not at all, but it does the job and is totally fine. I like the added logo in the background and it almost makes it feel like it is suppose to be like that, the logo on the protective glass, but what gives it away is the size of the logo. If you would have made it a bit smaller, so it actually doesn't go above the glass lines, that would have been cooler. Overall I like this piece and while it is not the most complicated piece, it still does the job and brings out the good looks of it!

Rating: 8/10