Player Worth: Trade Deadline Theme Week

[Steve 1,973]

[Thunder 1,225]

Graphic Review:

 

You got it…. I screwed up and got a trivia question wrong, so now I have to review your graphic for my 1 tpe.

 

At first glance the fox caught my attention.  (If it is not a fox and is a different animal, I apologize.  For purposes of this review I will call it a fox.). It grabs the graphic and makes me want to look at it more.  Upon further examination, I like the story it tells and the player just to the side of the fox makes the graphic more encompassing.  I like the smoke that surrounds the mouth and flows into the player, creating a mystic graphic.  I also like that you chose dark blue and black for the base and the smoke gives the ice some life.  

 

There is something on the right side of the graphic which I don’t know what it is, but I dont need to because it just adds to the mystery of the graphic and it makes it a complete graphic.  I like that you dont have a signature on this graphic as it would change it from a story to something else.  Good work.

 

Score 10/10

[Daniel Janser 2,239]

51 minutes ago, Thunder said:

Graphic Review:

 

You got it…. I screwed up and got a trivia question wrong, so now I have to review your graphic for my 1 tpe.

 

At first glance the fox caught my attention.  (If it is not a fox and is a different animal, I apologize.  For purposes of this review I will call it a fox.). It grabs the graphic and makes me want to look at it more.  Upon further examination, I like the story it tells and the player just to the side of the fox makes the graphic more encompassing.  I like the smoke that surrounds the mouth and flows into the player, creating a mystic graphic.  I also like that you chose dark blue and black for the base and the smoke gives the ice some life.  

 

There is something on the right side of the graphic which I don’t know what it is, but I dont need to because it just adds to the mystery of the graphic and it makes it a complete graphic.  I like that you dont have a signature on this graphic as it would change it from a story to something else.  Good work.

 

Score 10/10

It is a fire fox (also Red Panda) I think. and it is a bag of pucks... insinuating that this is the value of the depicted player (at least that is my story and I stick to it)

 

[Thunder 1,225]

1 hour ago, Daniel Janser said:

. and it is a bag of pucks.

I thought that is what it was but was too lazy to put my glasses on to verify.  Really good graphic.

[BOOM 8,883]

5 hours ago, Thunder said:

I thought that is what it was but was too lazy to put my glasses on to verify.  Really good graphic.

 

[Mr Bohannan 135]

One thing that always puts me off are these type of pieces where obviously it has a meaning and background story to it (which you kinda explained) or maybe it's some sort of an inside joke that some people will understand, but me, as a simply guy, I just look at the face value and get confused - is it genius piece or trash. This time I won't judge it in that way, so I will just give my commentary on the piece.

I like the idea of wanting to combine various elements together, but I feel a better job could have been doen. To bee fair after seeing your last piece, I know for a fact that a better job could have been done as I've seen that you can do so much better. I might be talking out of my arse right now and maybe the quality and the style of the piece is meant to be like this. Maybe you think that the player doesn't deserve more time spent on a piece for him, I dont know haha. Obviously it is not a terrible job as you did spend your time to cut it all out and put it all together and even did a jersey swap. Overall im just confused haha!

Rating: 6/10

[Steve 1,973]

On 1/22/2025 at 9:23 PM, Mr Bohannan said:

One thing that always puts me off are these type of pieces where obviously it has a meaning and background story to it (which you kinda explained) or maybe it's some sort of an inside joke that some people will understand, but me, as a simply guy, I just look at the face value and get confused - is it genius piece or trash. This time I won't judge it in that way, so I will just give my commentary on the piece.

I like the idea of wanting to combine various elements together, but I feel a better job could have been doen. To bee fair after seeing your last piece, I know for a fact that a better job could have been done as I've seen that you can do so much better. I might be talking out of my arse right now and maybe the quality and the style of the piece is meant to be like this. Maybe you think that the player doesn't deserve more time spent on a piece for him, I dont know haha. Obviously it is not a terrible job as you did spend your time to cut it all out and put it all together and even did a jersey swap. Overall im just confused haha!

Rating: 6/10

You are correct in every way. I rarely take time with theme weeks. It's a red panda and a player's value looks to be a pile of pucks. Your assessment is correct. Poorly made, iffy theme. Your rating is accurate.