Claimed:Jerrick Poole [Final: 6/6]

[Cuffy 346]

[iRockstar 307]

effort: 2/2 - clearly improving, I have no complaints in this department. 

 

look: 2.5/3 - You're certainly improving, but there is two major aspects that hurt this graphic. First is blending. Everything else is kind of blended nicely but then you look at the render and nothing. I'd suggest trying to make everything go over it, so that it looks blended into the sig better. Second is font placement. The choice is actually pretty good, but where it is, just makes it lack. Move it more over the render so I'm not looking further to the left to read it, but rather looking right at your focal point which should always be the render. 

 

creativity: 1/1 - yes

 

total: 5.5/6

[solas 1,951]

Effort: 2/2 - Clear improvement here. Nice job.

Look: 2.75/3 - The stock work is really well done here, and I like the coloring and lighting. Like IR said, some better blending would help - maybe by putting a stock or two over the render. Also, moving the text to the right - maybe so the left half of the text overlaps with the render and the right half is over the background - would definitely improve the composition of this sig.

Creativity: 1/1

Total: 5.75/6

FINAL GRADE: 6/6

[CoachReilly 688]

Claimed