That shouldn't matter as much as it seems, because there is both a mafioso and GF in this game. If hatty is one (which certainly he could be), the other would go for the kill.
I believe Dadam. Definitely more believable than a trapper claim. And the trap is already laid anyway so nbd if we are wrong. I think Ricer has got to be the vote here.
In the very least, vote Ricer to avenge Eagles.