Jump to content

2013-2014 NHL Discussion Thread


8Ovechkin8

Recommended Posts

Toews draws by far the most attention of anyone on the Hawks. You don't watch enough of the Hawks I don't think.

 

I guess Cam Fowler sucks.

Also Bonino and Cogs are not someone to leave alone either. They aren't household names but they are on pace for 50 points seasons

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderator

Selanne doesn't play with Getzlaf.

The line is Penner, Getz and Perry.

Though I'm not saying Toews is better necessarily. he did look really bad against my wings though.

I just like Getzlaf skillset more than his.

Edited by tfong
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Selanne doesn't play with Getzlaf.

The line is Penner, Getz and Perry.

Though I'm not saying Toews is better necessarily. he did look really bad against my wings though.

I just like Getzlaf skillset more than his.

Exactly my point. Neither does Kane play with Toews. People just seem to group together. I guarantee if I took Toews in a 1v1 with Getzlaf, Toews would perform Getz purely on the fact Toews is better defensively. So if you prefer Getz' great offensive ability and average defence to Toews Great offensive ability and well above average defensive ability, go right ahead.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderator

Exactly my point. Neither does Kane play with Toews. People just seem to group together. I guarantee if I took Toews in a 1v1 with Getzlaf, Toews would perform Getz purely on the fact Toews is better defensively. So if you prefer Getz' great offensive ability and average defence to Toews Great offensive ability and well above average defensive ability, go right ahead.

I look more of it as excellent offense, average defense vs great offense and good defensive.

Getz offense is a bit more than just slightly better. He is consistently better with 6+ seasons of ppg and more, he is currently riding a 1.2ppg pace. Toews has only ever been ppg once sofar and is ppg this season so it could be twice soon.

My other thought is I can always get a defensive specialist at a much cheaper price so the extra tier in offense I put as a premium. Plus the power game Getzlaf has is pretty hard to find these days in a top tier player.

An interesting comparison for the VHL is Smalling vs Rafter then.

Edited by tfong
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I look more of it as excellent offense, average defense vs great offense and good defensive.

Getz offense is a bit more than just slightly better. He is consistently better with 6+ seasons of ppg and more, he is currently riding a 1.2ppg pace. Toews has only ever been ppg once sofar and is ppg this season so it could be twice soon.

My other thought is I can always get a defensive specialist at a much cheaper price so the extra tier in offense I put as a premium. Plus the power game Getzlaf has is pretty hard to find these days in a top tier player.

An interesting comparison for the VHL is Smalling vs Rafter then.

Toews good defensively? Just good? I don't know about you but his constant Selke nominations (winning one) and PPG career pace is kind of better than Getz PPG career wise and no trophies. Don't get me wrong, Getz is a great player but I think you are putting too much weight on the power forward build. It's a great thing and he is strong, but he isn't overly physical like someone at his size would make you believe.

 

In a 7 games series, you'd lose.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderator

Fuck my phone crashed after typing.

I'll explain more later if u want but I basically typed out their top five ppg years sofar. I'll re type after my hockey game.

Look at their ppg in top five years. Getz is way ahead of Toews so the offensive margin is more than just a little bit. The reason why their career ppg is close is because Toews hit 60 points in his second season where it otook Getz 3 seasons. Also his 57 point season is a bit of an anomaly as his family member died that year.

But if you look at offensive peaks, Getz has a significant advantage of having 5 or more ppg season and above whereas Toews only has one. The raw numbers from those peaks are also higher.

Edited by tfong
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ryan Getzlaf's Career PPG - .956

GP      G        A         P     +/-     PIM    PPG SHG GWG      S      S%

600   175     399    574    101     548     61      5       34   1,398   12.5

 

Jonathan Toews Career PPG - .919

GP     G     A    P   +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG      S        S%

456 184 235 419 136 237 48        6       32    1,228   15.0

 

I don't know about you but .037 PPG isn't really that much better for Getz. So not sure what statistic you will pop out of your bag here. Like I said, Getz is a great player but 9/10 I would choose the guy who is a better defensive player in this situation (being Toews). In 150 less games Toews has only 2 less GWG, so their the clutch factor as well.

Edited by Kendrick
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderator

Ryan Getzlaf's Career PPG - .956

GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG S S%

600 175 399 574 101 548 61 5 34 1,398 12.5

Jonathan Toews Career PPG - .919

GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG S S%

456 184 235 419 136 237 48 6 32 1,228 15.0

I don't know about you but .037 PPG isn't really that much better for Getz. So not sure what statistic you will pop out of your bag here. Like I said, Getz is a great player but 9/10 I would choose the guy who is a better defensive player in this situation (being Toews). In 150 less games Toews has only 2 less GWG, so their the clutch factor as well.

You're ignoring what I said completely.

Take the top five point years each player has sofar. It shows that Getz has an much higher offensive peak. I'll show you when I get home, the difference is pretty significant.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You're ignoring what I said completely.

Take the top five point years each player has sofar. It shows that Getz has an much higher offensive peak. I'll show you when I get home, the difference is pretty significant.

When the career is done they don't look at the five best years Fong, they look at their total career stats. Otherwise Todd Bertuzzi should be a first ballot HOF

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderator

When the career is done they don't look at the five best years Fong, they look at their total career stats. Otherwise Todd Bertuzzi should be a first ballot HOF

 

We're not talking careers right now, we're just talking present time. Plus we are not looking at the entire body of work, just the statement that you think offensively there is very little difference but I believe there is a large difference.

 

So here is what I was typing before my phone crashed.

 

Getzlaf Top 5 PPG years

 

1.13, 1.12, 1.11, 1.06, 1.05 = 1.094

76+91+49+82+69 = 367 over 

 

Toews Top 5 PPG years

 

1.02, 0.97, 0.95, 0.89, 0.84 = 0.934

48+57+76+68+69= 318

 

Difference of 49 points or 15.4%

Or if we pro-rate the PPG to 82 games it is 0.16 difference or 17%

 

15%-17% offense increase is fairly significant.

 

If we look at this season alone, Getzlaf is at 1.2 and Toews at 0.98. That is a 22% difference.

 

Toews playoff offense production vs Getzlaf is also hugely in Getzlaf favour on an point level.

 

Yes I'm aware Toews has intangibles and faceoffs etc, but I'm speaking specifically on an offense level.

 

So your question is, is there a signifcant offense difference? Yes

Do I take this offensive advantage over the excellent two way play of Toews? Yes

 

Toews might break out, who knows, I could change my opinion next year even. I'm just looking at currently, Getz who is in beast mode vs Toews...who is doing pretty good. Love them both. 

 

Slight edge because I like Get'z offense and its not like his defense is terrible, it is underrated and decent if not slightly above your average offensive center. Will Toews get better in the offense department? who knows, he has 4 years on Getzlaf to show it, but I doubt it given how proficient he is as a two way player.

Edited by tfong
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...