a cool thing which is cool

[comrade cat 258]

alright so im bored and ask minion and ledge to make me a sig and it turned into a competition and yea i already decided but ledge gave me an idea to put it on a forum because why not
now this is how its gonna work im gonna show you the sigs and you reply by saying minion or a reason why you like whos now im not gonna write a 5000000 word thing soo just reply i guess
this is minions sig for Boris Tzesar (my player)  
This is Ledges i like em both but idk you pick. 

[comrade cat 258]

also i suck at making topics dont make fun of my shitty topic look ik it looks bad 

[jhatty8 662]

I like Ledge's more.

[Ricer13 2,593]

I like minions jersey and logo swap better. Overall though Ledge’s is more appealing to the eye. I vote Ledge.

[Dil 1,744]

Minion’s jersey swap makes it better than Ledge’s. If Ledge’s jersey swap didn’t look so abruptly placed it would be better.

[JardyB10 4,834]

I also came here to say Minion’s jersey swap was superior! I love that Ledge’s tender looks so shocked, and it is cleaner.

 

EDIT: That was supposed to say “render” but it turns out ‘tender is also appropriate.

 

I like the idea of the rain but I do think it dusts up the sig a bit. If it was replaced with a different effect or maybe put back a few layers, that might be better?

 

Overall, Ledge’s is simpler but I think it benefits from that and looks cleaner as a result. Minion’s is more “ambitious” and would probably take my vote with a couple little changes.

 

Both are fine work though.  

Edited November 15, 2021 by JardyB10

[Shindigs 1,771]

I mean Ledge purely because he's my GM. Because those eyes are hilarious.