Gustav

I hate how I never realized this was an actual technique despite opening up a .psd pack or two and knowing that it was being done. Good stuff; I'll try it out next time.

DAVID

...am I the only one who didn't know this?

It was just a CGY-NY deal except I just get Louis for nothing. Can't say I don't like my three-way trades though.

Two-way deals are for the feeble-minded

This was interrupted by theme week, but now that we're back--week 3.

That and just about everyone I called out (with the exception of Rory eventually) basically gave me a "shut up I'm not claiming." That's the single biggest red flag there is in this game--even more than being silent. Being silent does not work if town knows what they're doing--if you're evil get fake claims ready from the start and contribute to the conversation. It's a lot easier to separate good from evil when the good people come out with info and the evils say nothing and get hostile when asked for it. That being said, this was fun! I hope everyone else agrees. For a bit of an update on how I'm doing, my first couple weeks have been very manageable--so if things stay that way we could be seeing ToS #16 fairly soon...

Red = Dead Blue = Probably Confirmed 10x Town -Gustav (Coroner) -bigAL (Hacker) -RedSus (Librarian) -Blazzer (Two Truths and One Lie) -BarzalGoat (Fisherman) -Ptyrell (Demolitions Expert) -16z (Electoral College) -MMFLEX (Bunker Operator) -NotSoGood88 (Postman) -omgitshim (Gambler) -Ricer13 (Interrogator) This is 11, so if Al is Hacker that's one of the Any spots. 4x Mafia -eagles (Sniper) -jhatty8 (Sniper) -JeffD (Hangman) -Caboose30 (Ballot Destroyer) 3x Neutral -Doomsday (Jester) -Rory (Absorber) -Lefty_S (Two-Face) 1x ANY left and there has to be at least one evil. I'm betting Ledge is our Sniper. I actually believe that @bigAL is innocent at this point, but I don't want to list him as confirmed. I'm 80% sure that if we take out Ledge today, the game is over--though if that happens and it isn't, I'd say go for Al.

And I did read this--guess I should learn to read things and actually remember them; that would be helpful. Who's left on the suspicious list, just Ledge and Al?

VOTE LEDGE because I want to get at least one thing done and I'll be at work when the day phase ends. We should be voting Caboose as well today--if we can get both that would be great.

By the way, last night I investigated Doom to find our two-face, and Lefty was in the results...but I guess it doesn't matter since he's now dead and confirmed as the killer.

Red = Dead Blue = Probably Confirmed 10x Town -Gustav (Coroner) - fine I'll leave myself out of confirmed smh -RedSus (Librarian) -Blazzer (Two Truths and One Lie) -BarzalGoat (Fisherman) -Ptyrell (Demolitions Expert) -16z (Electoral College) -MMFLEX (Bunker Operator) -NotSoGood88 (Postman) -omgitshim (Gambler) -Ricer13 (Interrogator) 4x Mafia -eagles (Sniper) -jhatty8 (Sniper) -Hangman -Ballot Destroyer -There was a Sandman but they're probably dead or the current Sniper at this point. -Jeff is basically confirmed as Mafia 3x Neutral -Doomsday (Jester) -Rory (Absorber) -Lefty_S (Two-Face) 2x Any still out there at this point, I think--though I'm pretty sure one is Maf if we had a Hangman and Ballot Destroyer alive yesterday. Let's vote out Jeff and Caboose today; keep pushing Ledge and Al.

Can confirm I was attacked last night. Thank you Barzy! VOTE JEFF and let's get one more than the minimum on him because of the ballot destroyer. That was almost a big brain play by @rory; honestly big props to you for that one because I would have bought it if you didn't die last night. Jeff is obviously Mafia if the Ballot Destroyer helped him out; Caboose has to be evil at this point and I think Ledge is as well--if we've got three evils my money is on that. I don't have time to update the role list at the moment but I think we have three evils left? If we could get an actual specific role claim from @bigAL though that would be good since the lack of that is still raising eyebrows.

You're right--so we have the town list filled up but there's one any spot. I'd be willing to bet we'd be able to fill that any spot with 16z regardless of what their role was. Good call on that though; I was busy the other day and didn't pay much attention to omg's will. I still think I've got more or less the right call on the evils though. How would you feel about blowing up someone's house to confirm yourself, now that we've got a short list of people probably singled out as evil?

Tomorrow bb Patience is a virtue

There is, though he'd also have to get lucky to confirm someone specific being put to sleep two days in a row with it.

Oh shit you right. So right now, if our claims are all correct, we've got Hangman, Sniper, Absorber, and Two-Face between Jeff, Caboose, Al, and Ledge...assuming 16z was the Crusader. I'd also like to point out that Al came in super quickly to confirm that a couple people had been put to sleep...which isn't something I could find as an obvious consequence of any role here but which he'd certainly know if he were a member of the Mafia...

I worded this weird; hopefully it's understandable. 16z could have been the mystery Mafia member, but I'm almost positive that they were our Crusader instead.

I'd also like to add that if every claim above is legit, then 16z must have been the mystery Mafia member. He could have been a Town member though if one of our purported townies is lying. The more likely situation, though? 16z was our Crusader. Nobody's claimed it despite me annoying everyone without a claim so far, and as the Crusader death happened the same night as the Absorber death, they could have yote and been yeeted on the same night. Oh, and by the way--I forgot to include Hangman on the list of neutrals. If our town claims up to this point are legit, there's no claim space for Lefty being Introvert, and he therefore must be evil.

In case I get yeeted tonight here's a full claim list with what we have now. Red = Dead Blue = Probably Confirmed 10x Town -Gustav (Coroner) - fine I'll leave myself out of confirmed smh -RedSus (Librarian) -Blazzer (Two Truths and One Lie) -BarzalGoat (Fisherman) - I'll leave him out of confirmed for now but I think I trust him -Crusader (hasn't claimed yet but exists) -Ptyrell (Demolitions Expert) - no evidence one way or another yet -Rory (Electoral College) - we'll see tomorrow -MMFLEX (Bunker Operator) -NotSoGood88 (Postman) -omgitshim (Gambler) -Ricer13 (Interrogator) This is 11 town. If Barzal, Ptyrell, and Rory are all telling the truth, one of the ANY spots must be a Town member. 4x Mafia -eagles (Sniper) -jhatty8 (Sniper) -Sandman (might have been hatty though) -1 other Mafia - don't know yet 3x Neutral -Doomsday (Jester) -Absorber (either Rory/Jeff/Caboose, we'll know if it's Jeff today and if it isn't we'll see about Rory via election. If it isn't Jeff and Rory is good it's Caboose). -Two-Face (don't know who yet) -Lefty_S (claims Introvert) This is also 4 neutrals. If Lefty is telling the truth, the other ANY spot must be a Neutral. Lefty's claim is weak, though--so keep that in mind. Still no word from @bigAL (who said something but I didn't pick up on it and he didn't clarify) and @Ledge_and_Dairy on their roles. We have four evil spots left on the board, and the four I think are evil are: -Jeff -Caboose -Al -Ledge Rory has yet to be confirmed and I'm suspicious of Lefty's claim. If one of the four above turns out to be good, put Lefty on the list--and if either Blazzer or RedSus isn't Mayor tomorrow, put Rory on there as well. Ptyrell could also be evil as we haven't seen anything yet, but that makes sense given his claim and others look more sketchy at the moment. I think this list narrows it down really really well though.

I'm fine with this. I'm almost positive Jeff is evil and we get to confirm Rory as either good or evil tomorrow. @rory just to confirm, election is between RedSus and Blazzer? I think we should pick one of them to elect here while the day phase is still going and get our Crusader on them tonight (assuming being Electoral College doesn't mean you're visiting your nominees). Also, I'd like to point out that if Jeff isn't Absorber and if we confirm Rory as Electoral College...based on my results that would make Caboose the Absorber and a safe lynching tomorrow. Whether or not Rory is evil we get someone evil out of this. Also, since I've done this to everyone and it's only fair that I continue for everyone else: WHAT'S YOUR ROLE

Well that's not a fun role. Don't know how I missed that on the list. Has anyone visited Lefty?