Effort: 2/2 Sure
Look: 2.75/3 A bit dark for my liking and I've seen more from you in the past. I'm guessing you're a bit rusty from not doing sigs in a while.
Creativity: 1.1 Sure
Overall: 5.75/6
Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.75/3 A little needs some more vibrance/saturation. Missing that pop. The text and blending is nice though.
Creativity: 1/1 Yep
Overall: 5.75/6
Effort: 2/2 Sure
Look: 2.5/3 Was tempted to dock this more but overall it looks decent. I'd try and do some more stock work next time.
Creativity: 1/1 Sure
Overall: 5.5/6
Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.5/3 A bit grainy, could use a focal point...
Creativity: 1/1 Sure, even though I've seen this style quite a bit from you.
Overall: 5.5/6 - Final 6/6
Effort: 2/2 Sure
Look: 2.25/3 Needs some stock work. It's very simplistic, No real attempt to adjust the image at all aside from layering image and text and blurring a bit...
Creativity: 1/1 Sure
Overall: 5.25/6
Effort: 2/2 He's back!
Look: 3/3 Nothing major overall a great looking sig.
Creativity: 1/1 Yep this is a different style then what I've seen from you in the past.
Final 6/6
Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.5/3 I agree with munk the background needs work. I might suggest some more stock work next time as well...
Creativity: 1/1 Sure
Overall 5.5/6 ---> Final 6/6