Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.5/3 Like what you developed with the stock work and colouring. Text is bringing this down big time try placing it more to the right and under the arm of the smaller seguin render. The dots are adding nothing to this as well in the current position...
Creativity: 1/1 Yep
Overall: 5.5/6 Looks good just gotta work on that text placement.