Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.75/3 A bit bright for my liking. Need a stronger colour to mask the white/yellow primary colours.
Creativity: 1/1 Yep
Overall: 5.75/6
Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.5/3 Like what you developed with the stock work and colouring. Text is bringing this down big time try placing it more to the right and under the arm of the smaller seguin render. The dots are adding nothing to this as well in the current position...
Creativity: 1/1 Yep
Overall: 5.5/6 Looks good just gotta work on that text placement.
Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.75/3 Loving the pop and the colouring. I'm glad you added a light source on the render for a focal point.
Creativity: 1/1 Yep
Overall: 5.75/6
Effort: 2/2 The gregreg sig
Look: 2.75/3 Clean and fresh could use some more though most of your sigs have the same simplistic look, no disrespect intended.
Creativity: 1/1 Sure
Overall: 5.75/6
Effort: 2/2 Sure
Look: 2.75/3 A bit dark for my liking and I've seen more from you in the past. I'm guessing you're a bit rusty from not doing sigs in a while.
Creativity: 1.1 Sure
Overall: 5.75/6
Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.75/3 A little needs some more vibrance/saturation. Missing that pop. The text and blending is nice though.
Creativity: 1/1 Yep
Overall: 5.75/6
Effort: 2/2 Sure
Look: 2.5/3 Was tempted to dock this more but overall it looks decent. I'd try and do some more stock work next time.
Creativity: 1/1 Sure
Overall: 5.5/6
Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.5/3 A bit grainy, could use a focal point...
Creativity: 1/1 Sure, even though I've seen this style quite a bit from you.
Overall: 5.5/6 - Final 6/6
Effort: 2/2 Sure
Look: 2.25/3 Needs some stock work. It's very simplistic, No real attempt to adjust the image at all aside from layering image and text and blurring a bit...
Creativity: 1/1 Sure
Overall: 5.25/6
Effort: 2/2 He's back!
Look: 3/3 Nothing major overall a great looking sig.
Creativity: 1/1 Yep this is a different style then what I've seen from you in the past.
Final 6/6
Effort: 2/2 Yep
Look: 2.5/3 I agree with munk the background needs work. I might suggest some more stock work next time as well...
Creativity: 1/1 Sure
Overall 5.5/6 ---> Final 6/6