boubabi

That high pass filter looks awfull You should change the blend mode

Good trade

Tha fuck

Shiieetttt

Hope the bigger noob wins !

Meute Americans Titans Legion

Express 4-0

Not a huge fan of the right side effects and the text. Coloring is cool though.

yay me

yay me

Of course this is true for basically everytime but in this case, we are a website who gives points for efforts. So we need to evaluate the technique vs the result. I'm a big fan of minimalism because I'm the first to think that you don't need to put a mess in something to be concidere as a piece of art . But in this case, this is not a clean result or something like that. Minimalism is something that, put together, we don't see anything that can be added. But with this sig, it's looks like a unfinished collab. And the fact that the font is really noobish, it doesn't help. The render is kind of plain and the bg is boring. Of course the sesult is more important than the effort (most of the time) but in this case, the result is not that good so and I don't think you can claim the effort on this one too.

Agahaha

A great effort in a minimalisme art will usually result as an original piece of work. Originality brings often more criticisms but it pay off when you it the right point. Thats why Titans. (A guy from sportzin) use if influence in render efx to make everyone use topaz. And most of the time, it's was overdone and I do this too. But, what is my point is that is not originality. It's only basic graphic that (sorry to say that) a noob can do. There's no advanced technic in there. Colored font with a basic texture in the BG. White line on overlay. A strange shape, black and white face and thats pretty much it. I'm not trying to be rude, but you have the technic to do something way better than that, even if you try to do minimaliste art. If kesler would have done that, he would have received a 0/2 on effort and probably a 1.75 on looking. But you have done it and you would claim minimaliste art so you'll probably get out of that with a 5/6 or a 6/6 when this is not a 3/6 for me.

There is a difference between minimalist and lack of effort imo This can be concidere as minimalist Very basic sig but it's eye-attracting your sig looks like a 6 layers artwork imo

Not a big fan of this. The text is not really good. Render efx are basic and the Bg too. We can see bg from the cut bg this is not blended at all. The orange shape behind tavares is useless and disturning imo. you can do way better than that.

shieeeeeettt

I lol'ed

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY