Since I can't respond to it in the other thread, I'll respond in here.
"Yeah true it's not like he had more points than Miller or Faraday. He was in the top 25 for scoring of players not retired. I swear you guys just look at it blindly."
Yes, Shock had three more points than Miller last season. Miller, however, had five more goals and nearly 100 more hits. Also if you go back to S42, Miller was much better than Shock. And then if we want to bring attributes into it as part of the discussion as well, Miller is definitely the better of the two.
I know it doesn't matter because no one but Corco will be voting for him anytime soon, but I just figured since you're actually trying to defend him being on the list and not admitting you made a mistake, I'd point out that he's not that great.