Effort: 2/2 sure
Looks: 2.5/3 I love the text, just not a fan of the lighting on the bottom and top. I feel like it's missing something for a sig with a render right in the middle
Creativity: 1/1
overall: 5.5/6
Effort: 2/2 definitely improving
Looks: 2.5/3 The blending isn't the best and the lighting is non existent. Keep playing around though, you are definitely improving.
Creativity: 1/1
Overall: 5.5/6
Please pick one so I know which to grade! If you need advice post it in the graphics section here: http://www.vhlforum.com/index.php?/forum/100-graphics-designs-writing/
Effort: 2/2 Sure
Looks: 2/3 Cuffy nailed it. The dimensions on the sig make it look really weird though. Play around with different dimensions and try one's where its longer rather than shorter I believe I use 400x180 or 350x150...
Creativity: 1/1
Final: 5
Effort: 2/2 oh thank you sir!
Looks: 2.5/3 I like the idea! I just feel the text and the lighting could be better. Text is a tad hard to read.
Creativity: 1/1
Final: 6
Effort: 2/2 I'll give it to you this time
Looks: 1.5/3 Cuffy nailed it all really. The render sticks out way too much. Try to put some stocks over him or brush to blend him in. The text choice is fine but the placement isn't the best. Try working it into an area close to the render.
Creativity: 1/1 sure
final: 5
Effort:2/2
Looks:2.5/3 Yeah I agree with Cuffy here, the light stock at the bottom takes away a lot from the render and it looks washed out. Fix those and this would be really nice!
Creativity:1/1
Final: 6