Jump to content

boubabi

Members
  • Posts

    16,793
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    119

Posts posted by boubabi

  1. 3 hours ago, Shindigs said:

    Just join the dark side instead, we have cookies. And lots of saturation and cool effects. Usually it's just that it's "too much" and basically aimed at looking "cool" whereas professional graphic designers usually aim for "clean" and "professional" as more of their fighting words. But then that is usually because they aren't making forums sigs. If either of those posted graphics were forums sigs it would have been fine. But if they are marketing material for multi-billion dollar corporations, then that is really not okay. It's like you rocking up to a corporate meeting in your rave gear. There's nothing wrong with your rave gear, at a rave. It's just that in a corporate meeting it would make you look like you're 12 and lost. That's about the closest comparison I can make.

     

    Edit: Like if I showed her my forum sig she would facepalm. And rightfully so, because it's meant to be over the top like forum sigs should be. That's been what they've looked like stylistically since before some people on these forums were born. Because back then making something that looked that flashy was so hard in like Photoshop 5. That it was a flex just to be able to produce the effects. Eventually it became part of the forum culture, so here we are.

    This.

    The goal is not to roast, don't get me wrong. It's more about graphics that I either feel are lazy or have little to no design to it. Tbf, the matthews one is not that terrible design wise, there is just flaws that are easy to fix/poor decision. 

    First and foremost, it's over sharpened, the cyan/greenish color from the spark around the renders are terrible/doesn't fit, Matthews eyes are messed up on the smaller one and the face is over saturated/burned on the main render. That's a strikeout.

    On the other thread with images that aren't terrible, it's more about the design and the message. The patriot one is super clean as the render fx are interesting, the layout is interesting and there's enough content to it. Less is more, that is still true.

×
×
  • Create New...