So you won't ask him, but you'll sit here and debate this until its dead? I mean I can't help you with much of an explanation if you won't even ask your GM (who didn't vote for himself).
You can disagree sure, but I'd love to know why your own GM didn't vote for himself for an award you feel he should've one. You are in the minority, which isn't wrong but given the percentage of people that disagree with you, it doesn't bode well for your argument.