Effort: 2/2 Definitely have all the elements of a good sig.
Look: 2.5/3 My main issue is the low quality feel, might have been the stocks you used so adjusting the noise can help raise the quality so you can sharpen the image after without making it look terribad. I really love what you did the flow of this sig everything meshes well.
Creativity: 1/1 Yep Noah is the king of creativity...
Overall: 5.5/6 ---> 6/6