Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Admin

No just saying, because its edgar this is allowed. If it was me their is no way it would be allowed.

Establish a reputation of shitty players, don't be online 24/7, and be generally hipster and maybe you would reach Edgar level.
Link to comment
https://vhlforum.com/topic/20595-hsktor-s43/page/2/#findComment-223321
Share on other sites

Does it have to be accepted before the deadline to count, or simply posted? Realistically speaking we could always just have the blue team get pm'd every trade with acceptance from both sides before any post is made. Thus if something like this happens and Edgar isn't around to respond to a PM? Nothing goes through. 

 

#DoitliketheNHL

Link to comment
https://vhlforum.com/topic/20595-hsktor-s43/page/2/#findComment-223956
Share on other sites

Does it have to be accepted before the deadline to count, or simply posted? Realistically speaking we could always just have the blue team get pm'd every trade with acceptance from both sides before any post is made. Thus if something like this happens and Edgar isn't around to respond to a PM? Nothing goes through. 

 

#DoitliketheNHL

 

If that's the way it's decided we should do it, then fine. Regardless there shouldn't be silence on the matter. An announcement should be made clarifying how we are going to treat the deadline, considering a lot of people seemed to be under the impression that the deal would not be taking place. In the past, it has been such that a deal had to be publicly accepted by both sides before the deadline. If we are going to continue that practice, then this deal should not be an exception. Even if it's a case where "we'll look at how we want to do it in the off-season," it wouldn't make sense to make an exception and not just go with how it's been done. But if we're gonna change it now, then I see no problem with this trade going through.

 

Accepting trades through PM with the Blue Team changes nothing with what happened here. Edgar didn't reply his acceptance in the thread, so what makes you think he would have replied to a PM? I guess you didn't exactly say that anything would have been different, but I'm too lazy to change my wording. I don't think having trades accepted through PM with the Blue Team is a necessary change; the only thing that would really change in doing things that way is that we wouldn't have people commenting on the trade before the second side posts their acceptance, which could influence them to back out of the deal potentially.

Link to comment
https://vhlforum.com/topic/20595-hsktor-s43/page/2/#findComment-223962
Share on other sites

If that's the way it's decided we should do it, then fine. Regardless there shouldn't be silence on the matter. An announcement should be made clarifying how we are going to treat the deadline, considering a lot of people seemed to be under the impression that the deal would not be taking place. In the past, it has been such that a deal had to be publicly accepted by both sides before the deadline. If we are going to continue that practice, then this deal should not be an exception. Even if it's a case where "we'll look at how we want to do it in the off-season," it wouldn't make sense to make an exception and not just go with how it's been done. But if we're gonna change it now, then I see no problem with this trade going through.

 

Accepting trades through PM with the Blue Team changes nothing with what happened here. Edgar didn't reply his acceptance in the thread, so what makes you think he would have replied to a PM? I guess you didn't exactly say that anything would have been different, but I'm too lazy to change my wording. I don't think having trades accepted through PM with the Blue Team is a necessary change; the only thing that would really change in doing things that way is that we wouldn't have people commenting on the trade before the second side posts their acceptance, which could influence them to back out of the deal potentially.

 

I still don't know the ruling on deadline deals. As in I don't know if a deal needs to be accepted by both parties before the end of the deadline or just simply posted before then for it to be still considered acceptable.

 

Changing it to the other method would improve that, since realistically if Edgar didn't accept the trade via the PM before the deadline it wouldn't be considered official. 

Link to comment
https://vhlforum.com/topic/20595-hsktor-s43/page/2/#findComment-223969
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...