That would be a little more reasonable but where do we set the cap? Average of the players taking part maybe? The other thing is, if we did all-time players, who creates for the ones no longer with us? For example, Scotty isn’t around to make Campbell if he were to take part. It wouldn’t be hard to create him again but still.
Also, not that he would likely player for either side but Beketov vs. Beketov would be funny