Town of Salem #14

[Berocka 2,263]

So then, if Hatter is truth telling. Then Dooms has been Hexed N1, that means that OMG couldn't have been Hexed so he is actually evil.

 

So here is the plan. We vote up OMG. If he is innocent we know that Hatter is evil and Doom is most likely evil that Hatter was trying to protect him.

 

UNVOTE DOOMSDAY

 

VOTE OMG

[Mr_Hatter 1,608]

2 minutes ago, omgitshim said:

If all the TIs are legit, it would mean that I was hexed N1, Doom was hexed N2, and the Any spot is Town. 

I find it highly unlikely that a potential hex master would have hexed you N1. You called for a crusader on you, that's just daring a N1 death. So to me either Berocka or you are lying

[Berocka 2,263]

9 minutes ago, omgitshim said:

If all the TIs are legit, it would mean that I was hexed N1, Doom was hexed N2, and the Any spot is Town. Personally I find having 3 Sheriff claims very suspect (especially since two of them didn't cc when the first one came out, though Berocka had already told Flex at that point), though we had a game in EFL once with 4 Invests so it's not impossible.

So they show as sus the night they get hexed not the night after?

[Mr_Hatter 1,608]

3 minutes ago, Berocka said:

So then, if Hatter is truth telling. Then Dooms has been Hexed N1, that means that OMG couldn't have been Hexed so he is actually evil.

 

So here is the plan. We vote up OMG. If he is innocent we know that Hatter is evil and Doom is most likely evil that Hatter was trying to protect him.

 

UNVOTE DOOMSDAY

 

VOTE OMG

I am telling the truth, so I'm comfortable with this. The only potential issue is if you are lying about doom being sus, meaning that OMG could have been theoretically hexed N2.

@GustavMattiasif someone gets hexed and investigated in the same night, do they come up as sus? Assuming they were town. 

Because if this is the case, here is the deal; there is no way doom was hexed N1, because I found him NS. This means that EITHER OMG was actually hexed N1 and the hex master got lucky, OR OMG is lying. 

Then Doom was either Hexed N2, thus corroborating what both Berocka and I are saying, or he wasn't and Berocka is lying.

On the other hand, if they don't come up as sus until the next day, one of Berocka or OMG has to be lying because I found Doom as NS, meaning either Doom was hexed N1 and its impossible that OMG was hexed, or OMG had to have been hexed N1 and its impossible Doom was hexed. 

[Mr_Hatter 1,608]

1 minute ago, Berocka said:

So they show as sus the night they get hexed not the night after?

thats how I think it works. Hex Master is priority 3, sheriff is priority 4, meaning that the hex should go off first. In this case, the only way in which none of us is lying is if OMG was hexed N1 and Doom N2, which does adequately explain our results, but is really unlikely to me for the reasons I gave earlier (that OMG called for crusader N1)

[Mr_Hatter 1,608]

@MMFLEX care to share your thoughts? I still think we lynch OMG, since its unlikely imo that he was hexed N1. We need to start getting votes on if we don't want to waste the day. I think if he comes up as a NS role then we should wait a day and lynch Berocka or I, then jail and execute the other that night (N4), considering that if OMG is telling the truth then either Berocka or I are directly contradictory, but we don't want you to risk losing your executions. 

[MMFLEX 191]

2 minutes ago, Mr_Hatter said:

@MMFLEX care to share your thoughts? I still think we lynch OMG, since its unlikely imo that he was hexed N1. We need to start getting votes on if we don't want to waste the day. I think if he comes up as a NS role then we should wait a day and lynch Berocka or I, then jail and execute the other that night (N4), considering that if OMG is telling the truth then either Berocka or I are directly contradictory, but we don't want you to risk losing your executions. 

I'm quickly reading through, but I think it would be wise to lynch the sheriff instead of lynching the claimed BG. I'd rather lose a sheriff than BG. If Berocka comes up sheriff then we either have the vigi shoot omg, lynch him tomorrow, or omg was hexed.

 

Thoughts?

[Mr_Hatter 1,608]

1 minute ago, MMFLEX said:

I'm quickly reading through, but I think it would be wise to lynch the sheriff instead of lynching the claimed BG. I'd rather lose a sheriff than BG. If Berocka comes up sheriff then we either have the vigi shoot omg, lynch him tomorrow, or omg was hexed.

 

Thoughts?

Probably a good call, we do have more sheriffs than TP claims, and in a probable hex master game we get less and less useful. 

Obviously I'm a little disinclined because I directly got the sus result, but I'll go with what you want to do. It's more important that we do something productive, and either of these will narrow it down. 

[Berocka 2,263]

Look if we have to lynch me for the good of the town then so be it. But I think that it still might not give any information. With Hex being higher priority then Dooms could still have been hexed N2 and OMG N1 just means the Hexmaster called the bluff of crusader going on OMG.

 

Does Lynching me give any information when I come up Sherriff?

[omgitshim 902]

Hex works like Framing so it would show up the same night. 

 

11 minutes ago, MMFLEX said:

I'm quickly reading through, but I think it would be wise to lynch the sheriff instead of lynching the claimed BG. I'd rather lose a sheriff than BG. If Berocka comes up sheriff then we either have the vigi shoot omg, lynch him tomorrow, or omg was hexed.

 

Thoughts?

Hatter was the one that said I'm "sus", Berocka found Dooms as Sus, so I'm not sure how Berocka being actual Sheriff would make me evil?

[Spartan 4,406]

vote berocka? I guess

[Berocka 2,263]

When I show up as Sherriff all that does is prove that Doom is either Evil or Hexed...

[MMFLEX 191]

2 minutes ago, omgitshim said:

Hatter was the one that said I'm "sus", Berocka found Dooms as Sus, so I'm not sure how Berocka being actual Sheriff would make me evil?

Wrong person. I haven't caught all the way up yet.

[Spartan 4,406]

but would like to see some claims from the quiet folks, I've already claimed to flex in jail

[JorgTheGoat03 53]

2 minutes ago, Spartan said:

but would like to see some claims from the quiet folks, I've already claimed to flex in jail

This, the majority of the quiet people are probably non-townies. Thus, we should try to get claims from them.

[osens 297]

13 minutes ago, Spartan said:

but would like to see some claims from the quiet folks, I've already claimed to flex in jail

hey you stole my date and I DONT APPRECIATE IT OKAY!

[Spartan 4,406]

1 minute ago, osens said:

hey you stole my date and I DONT APPRECIATE IT OKAY!

I'll let you borrow @fishy for dinner one day  

[Ricer13 2,796]

WHO ARE WE VOTING FOR. I TRUST HATTER AND ONLY HATTER

[JorgTheGoat03 53]

20 minutes ago, Ricer13 said:

WHO ARE WE VOTING FOR. I TRUST HATTER AND ONLY HATTER

I DON'T KNOW WHO WE'RE VOTING FOR, BUT WE NEED TO START VOTING FOR THEM SOON.

[omgitshim 902]

Vote Hatter

[Ricer13 2,796]

Can we get an official vote count?

 

 

[Ptyrell 415]

Dead coven jumping on the 'suspect ptyrell' bandwagon that omg sorta started makes me more inclined to think omg is evil. Plus the fact that he didn't go to the jailor n2. Slightly sketchy to go after a BG claim though. 

 

I am fine with an omg vote, or a vote for one of the sheriff claims

[bigAL 2,176]

Vote count? I dunno who to hit 

[omgitshim 902]

1 minute ago, Ptyrell said:

Dead coven jumping on the 'suspect ptyrell' bandwagon that omg sorta started makes me more inclined to think omg is evil. Plus the fact that he didn't go to the jailor n2. Slightly sketchy to go after a BG claim though. 

 

I am fine with an omg vote, or a vote for one of the sheriff claims

 

Tbh the dead Coven jumping on it make me less sus of you

[MMFLEX 191]

Ok, we vote OMG. If we lose the BG then doctor has to go on me tonight and we let Jeff die. He can still seance.

 

vote OMG