Pandar

Well, when he puts up points, he's doing it in bunches. Can't complain about that.

Holy crap. I'll take 4 points every game, please and thank you.

Really solid. I like the text, good blending with the Bg. Solid work all around!

I like the color work on the text, and the b&w BG is effective. Nice work!

Great depth, fantastic lighting. Great piece!

My main complaint, is a lack of overall cohesion. It looks like a render on top of text on top of the background picture. You could do a lot with some additional stock work to make this look more like a single piece.

Dig the text, and if that's a JC it's well done. Not crazy about the BG, and the whole thing looks a little grainy, but that might just be this screen.

On the whole, I like it. I'm not sure you need the stroke on the first name. My only other complaint is that right behind his arm, it looks like you didn't blur the guy behind him on the black part (I assume it's a glove). Could use some other minor finishing touches, but it's a strong piece.

A little underwhelming tbh. The text is strong, imo, but it looks like this was pretty much just a picture that you put the text on. I can see that there's some filter work, but I'd like some more stock/effects work on the whole.

Good color work, and I like this text from you quite a bit. My biggest thing is that you rely heavily on blurring your render, which is a solid approach, but I feel like you do it just a little too strongly in general. If you play with using more and less blur in different areas of your sig, you can create a lot more depth Nice piece!

... I did not know this

@ChiefNoka4

Well God damn. This is fabulous in pretty much every regard. Great work!

Dig the text here, it's a lovely departure from your normal fare in that regard. All in all, it's a good piece. I'd like a little more from a lighting and layering perspective, but I feel like you're definitely making big strides forward!

Love the ideas going on here. There render looks a little LQ to me, and I'm not convinced that you need the white text but other than that I think this is really solid!

The render effects are really interesting. Not a fan of the text, but the rest of the sig is really nice imo

Cool dimensions. Love the text, and the color treatment is slick. It's very simple in a very aesthetically pleasing way. Great work

The hard diamond geometry is really interesting to me. I think I'd like a little more red/orange splashing in his face, but that's just me. Very cool piece!

On the whole, I dig this quite a bit. I do feel like it's not 100% cohesive, but I can't quite put my finger on why. Sorry... If it hits me I'll let you know!

On the whole, I like it. Maybe some lighting work to add depth to separate the player from the test of the BG? The text is fine, but nothing special imo.

@Banackock

Oh shit this is gorgeous. Love all of the effects, particularly the text. This is awesome. I've got nothing else to say

Love the text, love the effects, great work!

Really cool idea. My two main critiques would be that the blood splatters look kinda distorted, and I really don't like the font choice. You could also try to keep one guy in color, to better illustrate which player you're supposed to be representing with the sig.

Super sexy. Only thing I might not pick is the red circle on white reminds me of Japan, so if the sides not Japanese it could be kinda weird, maybe? On the whole, I love it.