Mafia Game #1 Thread

[Sixersfan594 247]

No one has info from last night?

 

I feel we have insane odds so just lay down some info and we'll get the ball rolling

[Psanchez55 59]

Godfather gone? Nice. Anyone have anything to go on for tonight?

[Gustav 6,469]

45 minutes ago, Psanchez55 said:

Godfather gone? Nice. Anyone have anything to go on for tonight?

Not really "anything to go on" so much as "now wondering who's mafia/neutral pretending to be town"

[Enorama 2,039]

27 minutes ago, GustavMattias said:

Not really "anything to go on" so much as "now wondering who's mafia/neutral pretending to be town"

 

I'll answer that one for you: each of the mafia/neutral remaining.

[Enorama 2,039]

1 hour ago, HulkHogan said:

well i was roleblocked

 

So we have an escort or consort among us. Also means Hulk has a role he can execute.

[Gustav 6,469]

Just now, Enorama said:

 

I'll answer that one for you: each of the mafia/neutral remaining.

Fair enough. First mafia game for me, but I suppose that's just common sense.

[Psanchez55 59]

Again, it's very quiet. Not even a single lynch vote has been thrown out there. Kinda surprising. 

[Nykonax 1,566]

Just for the record I inform everyone if they are role blocked, even if they don't have a night ability

[omgitshim 903]

So since no one is stepping up and it's been quiet, here's what we know so far (was hoping to get this up before the deadline but it took a lot longer to type than I expected):

 

GODFATHER - MMFLEX (Assassin Kill) *Voted for Lat night 1

MAFIOSO

MAFIA X4

ASSASSIN
EXECUTIONER - Josh (SK kill) *Voted for Sharkstrong night 1

RANDOM NEUTRAL
MAYOR

MEDIUM

VANILLA - Matt_O (Maf Kill)

TOWN X14

 

Currently, MexicanCow123, FusRoDah, FakeJenton, & ahawk2191 have not said a word at all. In addition, both Walter Fizz and Sullvino each have one post with no real contribution to the game. HulkHogan has claimed roleblocked, so that puts either Escort or Consort in play (probably not both since we only got the 1 roleblock). fonziGG, BladeMaiden, GustavMattias, TacticalHammer all have some generic posts. xsjack was on the no lynch day 1 side. Sixersfan549 has been pushing for info quite a bit and has generally been more active than most. Sharkstrong was anti-lynch day 1 since town has numbers, but was more pro-lynch day 2 on one of the quieter people. Enorama meme voted the Godfather day 1 and has been active in the thread so far. omgitshim retracted his meme vote from the Godfather which is sus af. TheLastOlympian07 jokingly suggested to kill Sixers (seemed more like banter than anything though), then supported Shark. Matmenzinger suggested Shark might be mafia after TLO supported him. Symmetrik claimed to be the master that sent the assassin after MMFLEX, and with no counter claim on that, makes him very likely to not be mafia. LattimoreIsland has been all memes; MMFLEX voted for him day 1 while he voted (and then unvoted Poptart). Possible Jester but with only one unknown Neutral left and him being quiet today that seems unlikely. Devise hasn't said much but is on the no lynch train as well. Poptart has been pretty active overall, suggested Sym was sus after the night day post but that's likely due to Nyko name dropping him. Psanchez55 has also been active quite a bit but has mostly just commented on how quiet it's been.

[Nykonax 1,566]

Day 2 Results

 

The Town stays up a little late debating on who to hang. Overall most people mind their own business, but nothing really comes out of it.

 

 

Please DM me on Discord or Forums your night action by 9:00AM EST

[TacticalHammer 95]

53 minutes ago, omgitshim said:

So since no one is stepping up and it's been quiet, here's what we know so far (was hoping to get this up before the deadline but it took a lot longer to type than I expected):

 

GODFATHER - MMFLEX (Assassin Kill) *Voted for Lat night 1

MAFIOSO

MAFIA X4

ASSASSIN
EXECUTIONER - Josh (SK kill) *Voted for Sharkstrong night 1

RANDOM NEUTRAL
MAYOR

MEDIUM

VANILLA - Matt_O (Maf Kill)

TOWN X14

 

Currently, MexicanCow123, FusRoDah, FakeJenton, & ahawk2191 have not said a word at all. In addition, both Walter Fizz and Sullvino each have one post with no real contribution to the game. HulkHogan has claimed roleblocked, so that puts either Escort or Consort in play (probably not both since we only got the 1 roleblock). fonziGG, BladeMaiden, GustavMattias, TacticalHammer all have some generic posts. xsjack was on the no lynch day 1 side. Sixersfan549 has been pushing for info quite a bit and has generally been more active than most. Sharkstrong was anti-lynch day 1 since town has numbers, but was more pro-lynch day 2 on one of the quieter people. Enorama meme voted the Godfather day 1 and has been active in the thread so far. omgitshim retracted his meme vote from the Godfather which is sus af. TheLastOlympian07 jokingly suggested to kill Sixers (seemed more like banter than anything though), then supported Shark. Matmenzinger suggested Shark might be mafia after TLO supported him. Symmetrik claimed to be the master that sent the assassin after MMFLEX, and with no counter claim on that, makes him very likely to not be mafia. LattimoreIsland has been all memes; MMFLEX voted for him day 1 while he voted (and then unvoted Poptart). Possible Jester but with only one unknown Neutral left and him being quiet today that seems unlikely. Devise hasn't said much but is on the no lynch train as well. Poptart has been pretty active overall, suggested Sym was sus after the night day post but that's likely due to Nyko name dropping him. Psanchez55 has also been active quite a bit but has mostly just commented on how quiet it's been.

Depending what happens overnight, I'd be down to start lynching inactives tomorrow.

[omgitshim 903]

2 minutes ago, TacticalHammer said:

Depending what happens overnight, I'd be down to start lynching inactives tomorrow.

 

Sounds like a plan to me.

[Psanchez55 59]

1 minute ago, TacticalHammer said:

Depending what happens overnight, I'd be down to start lynching inactives tomorrow.

Town going to struggle to win if the assassin is the only one hitting mafia until the roles feel safe revealing

[xsjack 132]

maybe we could afford a Lynch for day 3 but it would be risky would not want to kill another town

[MexicanCow123 915]

1 hour ago, omgitshim said:

So since no one is stepping up and it's been quiet, here's what we know so far (was hoping to get this up before the deadline but it took a lot longer to type than I expected):

 

GODFATHER - MMFLEX (Assassin Kill) *Voted for Lat night 1

MAFIOSO

MAFIA X4

ASSASSIN
EXECUTIONER - Josh (SK kill) *Voted for Sharkstrong night 1

RANDOM NEUTRAL
MAYOR

MEDIUM

VANILLA - Matt_O (Maf Kill)

TOWN X14

 

Currently, MexicanCow123, FusRoDah, FakeJenton, & ahawk2191 have not said a word at all. In addition, both Walter Fizz and Sullvino each have one post with no real contribution to the game. HulkHogan has claimed roleblocked, so that puts either Escort or Consort in play (probably not both since we only got the 1 roleblock). fonziGG, BladeMaiden, GustavMattias, TacticalHammer all have some generic posts. xsjack was on the no lynch day 1 side. Sixersfan549 has been pushing for info quite a bit and has generally been more active than most. Sharkstrong was anti-lynch day 1 since town has numbers, but was more pro-lynch day 2 on one of the quieter people. Enorama meme voted the Godfather day 1 and has been active in the thread so far. omgitshim retracted his meme vote from the Godfather which is sus af. TheLastOlympian07 jokingly suggested to kill Sixers (seemed more like banter than anything though), then supported Shark. Matmenzinger suggested Shark might be mafia after TLO supported him. Symmetrik claimed to be the master that sent the assassin after MMFLEX, and with no counter claim on that, makes him very likely to not be mafia. LattimoreIsland has been all memes; MMFLEX voted for him day 1 while he voted (and then unvoted Poptart). Possible Jester but with only one unknown Neutral left and him being quiet today that seems unlikely. Devise hasn't said much but is on the no lynch train as well. Poptart has been pretty active overall, suggested Sym was sus after the night day post but that's likely due to Nyko name dropping him. Psanchez55 has also been active quite a bit but has mostly just commented on how quiet it's been.

What do you mean i have not said a word. I'm playing the game.

[omgitshim 903]

2 minutes ago, MexicanCow123 said:

What do you mean i have not said a word. I'm playing the game.

 

I meant you haven't posted in the thread yet. Usually people who don't post at all are either trying to be secretive or are inactive. The thread in general has been pretty inactive so hopefully we'll get some more info tomorrow and we can have a proper discussion.

[Gustav 6,469]

9 minutes ago, MexicanCow123 said:

What do you mean i have not said a word. I'm playing the game.

Suspicious...could this indicate MexicanCow is in the mafia? 

[MexicanCow123 915]

Just now, GustavMattias said:

Suspicious...could this indicate MexicanCow is in the mafia? 

Maybe?!?!?

[Matmenzinger 167]

May I start writing a will to be posted upon my death, town of salem style?

[BladeMaiden 1,807]

Every time I take in these games i die within the first 5 min, regardless of my role lol

 

Question is who how to we sniff out those killing? Someone has to have information.

[Sullvino 289]

27 minutes ago, BladeMaiden said:

Every time I take in these games i die within the first 5 min, regardless of my role lol

 

Question is who how to we sniff out those killing? Someone has to have information.

 

At this time, I have no information 

[TheLastOlympian07 2,388]

well that was a crazy first night. lol.

[Nykonax 1,566]

Night 2 Results

The town wakes up at dawn and finds 3 people noticably missing. 

 

First they head to @GustavMattias house. They see his bloody body with not only a bullet wound, but also 90 stabs in it. Seems a little over kill if you ask me. He was wearing a nice dress, he must've been the Escort

 

Laying next to the body is @xsjack's body, but without a bullet holes and only some serious stab wounds. He had a gun on him and could only be the Mafioso

 

Finally they head to @ahawk2191's house. He has a clean bullet holes right through his head, and nothing in his house was disturbed. He was surrounded by about 30 fishing rods. He was the town's Fisherman

[omgitshim 903]

GODFATHER - MMFLEX (Assassin Kill) *Voted for Lat night 1

MAFIOSO - xsjack (SK Kill)

MAFIA X4

ASSASSIN
EXECUTIONER - Josh (SK kill) *Voted for Sharkstrong night 1

RANDOM NEUTRAL
MAYOR

MEDIUM

VANILLA - Matt_O (Maf Kill)

ESCORT - GustavMattias (Maf & SK Kill?)

FISHERMAN - ahawk2191 (Assassin Kill)

TOWN X12

 

Well we got the Mafioso which is good, but we lost two town in the process. Fortunately it wasn't an investigative role or a direct protection, so that's probably a good trade since we still have numbers. Escort would validate Hulk's claim, but our Medium can ask Gustav if he blocked him. If not that probably means we have a Consort as well (or Hulk is lying but given the role block claim was his first post, that would be a weird thing to lie about).

 

Finally I'd like to apologize to ahawk. I was the Master last night and thought one of the quiet people had to be mafia, but looks like I made the wrong choice.

[Enorama 2,039]

I am confusion.

 

3 kills but it appears to be 4 killing roles?

 

Mafioso, serial killer, and assassin for sure. Maybe Gus was also shot by the Hunter? That's what makes the most sense to me.