boubabi

You added mediocrity fo sho

Yes I have a multi somewhere.

i voted for the goaltender because 2100 saves is very good
 
He saved like 2100 goals. THATS INSANE
 
2100 goals saved > 35 goals scored
 
Amirite

i voted for the goaltender because 2100 saves is very good
 
He saved like 2100 goals. THATS INSANE
 
2100 goals saved > 35 goals scored
 
Amirite

i voted for the goaltender because 2100 saves is very good
 
He saved like 2100 goals. THATS INSANE
 
2100 goals saved > 35 goals scored
 
Amirite

I would argue that the first image, he's going further from me but I see your point
 
gritty isn't even the best mascot in his town

@tfong
 
Oh sorry, I thought you meant the biggest joke on discord

@tfong
 
Oh sorry, I thought you meant the biggest joke on discord

A couple additional versions since I couldn't decide, thanks for the feedback @boubabi
 

 

 

 
I kinda liked the Old English style personally, but figured it looked better without the "RYAN".  Decided to try two different styles of the right-side text.  Regardless, I appreciate the help with these last few adjustments  

The foundation of the idea is good, but I don't think the VHL has the ressource to execute perfectly the idea.
 
First of all, even though some member has some logo design basic knowledge, we arent really tooled like a professional graphic designer. Even if the logo was perfect, some people won't like it for some reason. From my VHL experience, people are afraid of changes and would rather keep something familiar but ugly than new and superior (see the calgary logo)
 
From my stand of view, I would consider the criticism of 1 professional logo designer over the opinion of 100 members with no experience with that. I know we like to think its part of the democratic process, but it really shouldn't for those type of things
 
In my opinion, if we want to take a step further in branding those teams, all teams should have :
 
1. the official ai logo available for download
2. an official color scheme for jersey and shits
3. an official typeface/ logotype for the franchise
4. a secondary logo/secondary jersey
 
all those in vector formats of course
 
So if that's the goal of the committee, why not. But otherwise, I think its quite hard to give feedback when everyone has their own (even though they might not be good ones)
 

The foundation of the idea is good, but I don't think the VHL has the ressource to execute perfectly the idea.
 
First of all, even though some member has some logo design basic knowledge, we arent really tooled like a professional graphic designer. Even if the logo was perfect, some people won't like it for some reason. From my VHL experience, people are afraid of changes and would rather keep something familiar but ugly than new and superior (see the calgary logo)
 
From my stand of view, I would consider the criticism of 1 professional logo designer over the opinion of 100 members with no experience with that. I know we like to think its part of the democratic process, but it really shouldn't for those type of things
 
In my opinion, if we want to take a step further in branding those teams, all teams should have :
 
1. the official ai logo available for download
2. an official color scheme for jersey and shits
3. an official typeface/ logotype for the franchise
4. a secondary logo/secondary jersey
 
all those in vector formats of course
 
So if that's the goal of the committee, why not. But otherwise, I think its quite hard to give feedback when everyone has their own (even though they might not be good ones)
 

The foundation of the idea is good, but I don't think the VHL has the ressource to execute perfectly the idea.
 
First of all, even though some member has some logo design basic knowledge, we arent really tooled like a professional graphic designer. Even if the logo was perfect, some people won't like it for some reason. From my VHL experience, people are afraid of changes and would rather keep something familiar but ugly than new and superior (see the calgary logo)
 
From my stand of view, I would consider the criticism of 1 professional logo designer over the opinion of 100 members with no experience with that. I know we like to think its part of the democratic process, but it really shouldn't for those type of things
 
In my opinion, if we want to take a step further in branding those teams, all teams should have :
 
1. the official ai logo available for download
2. an official color scheme for jersey and shits
3. an official typeface/ logotype for the franchise
4. a secondary logo/secondary jersey
 
all those in vector formats of course
 
So if that's the goal of the committee, why not. But otherwise, I think its quite hard to give feedback when everyone has their own (even though they might not be good ones)
 

Not huge on the stroke for the player but I like the concept a lot. The text on the right side could be a different typo, (maybe higher length, a little bit tighter) and behind the render, but it works as it is anyway. The background image could use a bit more pop, or do the opposite and be very subtle and blend it with a white background
 
But still a solid sig. The concept is nice, which is a huge plus

The red font doesnt work. The red areas on the render are oversaturated. You could add a slight rim light on a side of the render to blend it better with the white bg, like he was backlit 

slow down donald trump

slow down donald trump

Honestly not much to critique. Most of my complaints would be audio related. Some of the SFX just didn’t seem to line up well and the music to me just didn’t really fit the cut that well. Like it felt as if it should have built a lot more than it did.
 
In general the pacing was a bit slow but I guess that was the point? Just kinda had nothing happening and then everything happening, would have liked to see things maybe building more tension. Like I loved the mist crawling up through the house, give me more of that tension building the whole time to get the creepy atmosphere going.
 
Being picky there were a couple of shots that weren’t super blended. The phone dangling felt like it didn’t belong in the atmosphere for some reason to me and a few shots of the mist felt like it wasn’t clinging to surfaces as I’d expect.
 
Overall though, very well done. Some scenes obviously looked better than others (the fish on the beach was A+, looked like live action aside from its eyes feeling weird) but nothing was truly bad.

to finish my degree in 3d animation, I was part of this
Cheers

to finish my degree in 3d animation, I was part of this
Cheers

to finish my degree in 3d animation, I was part of this
Cheers

to finish my degree in 3d animation, I was part of this
Cheers

the mix of light grey, dark grey, black and white doesn't really work here
 
its a bit of a fuckfest

to finish my degree in 3d animation, I was part of this
Cheers