My "Following the rules" list:
[b][u][size=5]Team Followed:[/size][/u][/b] PENS. [b]Center:[/b]Mario Lemieux [b]Right Wing:[/b]Mark Recchi [b]Left Wing:[/b]Bill Guerin (for the purposes of this, he can play opposite side) [b]Defenseman:[/b]Brooks Orpik [b]Defenseman:[/b]Sergei Gonchar [b]Goaltender:[/b]Ty Conklin (fuck Fleury)
HM: Dick Tarnstrom, Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin (waaay too many centers as opposed to just about any other forward position, and Tarnstrom was great but for a defenseman he didn't play much defense *cough Mike Green cough*)
My "No one cares about 10 years" list (because these are the guys I grew up on and why I love hockey):
[b][u][size=5]Team Followed:[/size][/u][/b] PENS. [b]Center:[/b]Ron Francis (only because Lemieux is already on the other list) [b]Right Wing:[/b]Joe Mullen [b]Left Wing:[/b]Luc Robitaille [b]Defenseman:[/b]Jim Paek [b]Defenseman:[/b]Darius Kasparaitis [b]Goaltender:[/b]Tom Barrasso
HM: Kevin Hatcher, Ulf Samuelsson Paul Coffey, Frank Pietrangelo, Ken Wregget, Kevin Stevens, Rick Tocchet, Troy Loney
All time full roster, comprised only of guys I've seen play (TV counts):
Joe Mullen - Mario Lemieux - Luc Robitaille
Kevin Stevens - Sidney Crosby - Mark Recchi
Petr Nedved - Ron Francis - Bill Guerin
Troy Loney - Evgeni Malkin - Rick Tocchet
Paul Coffey - Brooks Orpik
Sergei Gonchar - Darius Kasparaitis
Kevin Hatcher - Ulf Samuelsson
Tom Barrasso
Frank Pietrangelo
Scratches:
Jim Paek (because at least a small amount of realism: Paek was by far the worst of these defensemen)
Ed Olczyk
Ken Wregget.