S67 Public Player Vote (Forward,Defence, Goalie) Super Thread

[Devise 4,475]

11 minutes ago, Rayzor_7 said:

I understand where you're coming from and I'm not sure about the other goalie, but take a look at Seattle and tell me which forward should be there. Kovalchuk switched mid-season, Oliver defensemen and forwards are good but they're also rookies just like me. Comparatively I have a good shot at Rookie of the year well none of my teammates do. so while I get your mad that I take up one of four slots rather than one of 12 or one of eight, I feel the GM selection is still a good thing. It seems should still have at least one representative

 

I don't think it'd matter if we had say 6 goalies in. The issue isn't that your an All Star, it's that with only 4 goalie slots no matter what if GM's opt to select goalies who fall in on the 5th or 6th ranking (which you guys do, Kallis, Pepper Wahl and Rift are the top 4 goalies this season) then no matter what a top net minder gets the snub. I also think it's presumptuous to assume every team will have an ASG worthy player. What if a rebuilding club sucks and their goalie sucks and their top scorer has 50 points? 

 

Again, "generally" that shouldn't be a big deal because it's just one vote. But as we have clearly seen with this format, if enough GM's take up a specific position, the voting is only allowed to grab so many players. So you can easily wind up in a situation where that one off 50 point scorer who you grab for representation winds up in while several players over a point per game aren't because the GM's selected too many forwards and only so many of the forward votes go in. 

 

I totally get the community engagement aspect Beaviss is going for, but there is a reason when the NHL does it's All Star game stuff, even it's community or fan votes, they hard lock position limits and the rest. At the end of the day if we wind up in a system where the "top" player of any field, D goalie or forward, ISN'T in the All Star Game, then something is wrong with the format. There should never be a situation where the top point getter, the top goal scorer, the top d in scoring, and the top goalie stats shouldn't be an All Star. It's not about me being mad for my player, it's about the format lacking the right approach so as to make sure at the very least even the most "obvious" All Stars are in.

 

If there are only 4 goalie slots GM's shouldn't be allowed to nominate a goalie. Knowing all this, if this is the format next season, what's stopping all of us GM's from just making a complete mockery of this and nominating whomever? Hell we could nominate 4 goalies, all of whom are worst than the top one. Nothing is stopping us from doing that.  If the top statistical players in a category can get FISTED ANALLY BY A CIRCUS MONKEY because of GM nominations, what does it even matter who goes in at that point? It's arbitrary. 

Edited August 30, 2019 by Devise

[Beaviss 4,957]

9 minutes ago, Devise said:

If there are only 4 goalie slots GM's shouldn't be allowed to nominate a goalie. Knowing all this, if this is the format next season, what's stopping all of us GM's from just making a complete mockery of this and nominating whomever? Hell we could nominate 4 goalies, all of whom are worst than the top one. Nothing is stopping us from doing that.  If the top statistical players in a category can get FISTED ANALLY BY A CIRCUS MONKEY because of GM nominations, what does it even matter who goes in at that point? It's arbitrary. 

 

Its always been arbitrary it doesn't show up in your awards or anything its for "fun" that's the keyword. Its supposed to engage the community and having a player from each team means more people will care about tuning in and watching and engaging since they have a player to cheer for on their team. Ive missed the ASG by a couple votes but it didn't matter to me since I understand its for fun.

 

If the top player in the league or the best goalie in the league gets FISTED ANALLY BY A CIRCUS MONKEY that's their GM's fault for not electing them. If a GM chooses to nominate a 2nd tier player instead of the top guy on the team and he misses the game that's between the player and the GM not the structure of the ASG itself.

[ShawnGlade 1,010]

i think ive been an allstar in every season so far

[Gustav 6,407]

On 8/28/2019 at 11:14 AM, Beaviss said:

All Participants:

All Star Selection: 1 TPE

Win the Game: 2 TPE

 

Skaters:

1st Star: 3 TPE

2nd Star: 2 TPE

3rd Star: 1 TPE

GWG: 1 TPE

Hat trick: 3 TPE

Three Assists: 1 TPE *

 

Goalies:

.850+ Save%: 3 TPE

Two Periods Played: 1 TPE 

 

There will be a 5 TPE earned cap for the rewards.

*new

I have a question!

 

How should I interpret the top part?

-I get 1 TPE for being selected, plus 2 more if my team wins; or,

-I get 1 TPE for being selected, plus 1 more to make it 2 if my team wins?

[Beaviss 4,957]

7 minutes ago, GustavMattias said:

I have a question!

 

How should I interpret the top part?

-I get 1 TPE for being selected, plus 2 more if my team wins; or,

-I get 1 TPE for being selected, plus 1 more to make it 2 if my team wins?

 

1 for selected two if you win i should really re word that

[Gustav 6,407]

1 minute ago, Beaviss said:

1 for selected two if you win i should really re word that

So the second one?

[Beaviss 4,957]

1 minute ago, GustavMattias said:

So the second one?

 

yes

[Steve 1,920]

So the "All Star" game players get TPE but the WJC didn't get squat. Seems fair.....................

[Gustav 6,407]

On 8/28/2019 at 11:15 AM, Beaviss said:

Codrick Past @Victor

What have you done? You didn't write "Cast;" now @Victor will never know he made the all-star game!

[Victor 10,940]

11 minutes ago, GustavMattias said:

What have you done? You didn't write "Cast;" now @Victor will never know he made the all-star game!

Wow Cast got voted for something!

[gorlab 4,321]

Votes for Matt Thompson will be diverted to Jet Jaguar.

[Beaviss 4,957]

ALL STAR TEAMS:

Sorted in order of picking per team.

 

TEAM @Devise:

Tzuyu @tfong

Ryan Sullivan Jr @Advantage

Smitty Werbenjagermanjensen @flyersfan1453

Rauno Palo @jRuutu

Paolo Nano @leafsman

Beau Louth @Beaviss

Oyorra Arroyo @omgitshim

Matthew Materazo @Matt_O

Diljodh Starload @DilIsPickle

Dan Baillie @wcats

Wahl @BladeMaiden

Rayz Funk @Rayzor_7

 

 

TEAM @Victor:

Podrick Cast @Victor

Pepper @Sonnet

Matt Thompson @Beketov

Joseph McWolf @McWolf

Veran Dragomir @Velevra

Ryan Kastelic @Enorama

Shawn Glade @ShawnGlade

Finn Davison @Poptart

Dan Wilinsky @oilmandan

Boris the Forest @chillzone

Sidney Crosby @SidTheKid87

Jerry Garcia @GustavMattias

 

Game will most likely be simmed on Saturday afternoon (exact time to be announced later)

[Gustav 6,407]

TEAM VICTOR

[Rayzor_7 741]

8 minutes ago, GustavMattias said:

TEAM VICTOR

You do know me and you were the last two picked right?

[chillzone 231]

Team Victor ✌

[BladeMaiden 1,807]

@Devise you really screwed up... have you not seen how Brick does in all-star games. This will end badly...

[Dil 1,760]

@Devise disappointed  you picked me so low

[omgitshim 901]

3 hours ago, BladeMaiden said:

@Devise you really screwed up... have you not seen how Brick does in all-star games. This will end badly...

 

It's ok I'm on the team, so you'll be fine.

[BladeMaiden 1,807]

3 hours ago, omgitshim said:

 

It's ok I'm on the team, so you'll be fine.

 

Nothing helps Wahl in ASGs...

 

but maybe if @Beaviss made me disco Wahl pads my luck would change... oh and boost my stats while your at it  lol

 

can’t blame a girl for trying!!

[Victor 10,940]

Let’s give Cast - Thompson another go @Beketov. Can’t be as bad as the Sponsors Shield can it?

[Beketov 9,025]

5 hours ago, Victor said:

Let’s give Cast - Thompson another go @Beketov. Can’t be as bad as the Sponsors Shield can it?

Well the EA game sims and I tend to not agree on a lot of things but yeah, it can’t be as bad as the SST haha

[wcats 237]

When does this game happen?

[Beaviss 4,957]

@Rayzor_7

 

19 hours ago, wcats said:

When does this game happen?

 

In about 3 hours