Ranking VHLM teams by VHL draft success

[dlamb 1,326]

 Ranking VHLM teams by VHL draft success

 

Ever since joining VHL, something I wanted to do is a research Media Spot. I’m finally bored of graphics enough to start this one, and I had a pretty fun time coming up with it. I am going to be ranking all active VHLM teams using their player’s success in the VHL Draft.

 

DISCLAIMER: This is all in good fun. My research is not perfect, and do not take it as serious, and do not judge GMs and their teams based on the rankings. I have no mal intent towards any team, my data does not contain full drafts, nor all years, and does not factor in the hard work VHLM GMs do recruiting and retaining players. Also, when I say waiver signed, that refers to signed as a free agent prior to their VHLM draft.

I looked through each player from the S71 through S75 draft drafted in the 1^st round of the VHL Entry Draft, and wrote down the team they were drafted from, whether they are a first-generation player or not, and the VHLM waiver team they were picked up by. If a VHLM team had one of their players drafted in the first round of the VHL draft, they were awarded 2 points. This is the main factor I want my rankings to be based on, thus being my highest point share. If the player was a first generation, the VHLM team was awarded an extra point. I believe, as much as the VHLM may or may not have had a personal impact on the player, most first-generation players need closer attention from a GM, thus the bonus. Finally, the VHLM team that originally picked the player off of waivers was awarded 1 point, as an homage to being their original team. This is where I’m not fully confident, as some waiver teams may have had a higher impact on the player than the team awarded 2 points. However, for a fun little research article, I think it works well enough.

 

----

 

Without further ado, here are the rankings:

(all stats are from S71 VHL Entry Draft through S75 VHL Entry Draft ONLY)

 

12. Philadelphia Reapers

TOTAL SCORE: 10

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 2

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 1

Waiver-signed Score: 5

Highest Drafted Player: Jolly Greene Giant, 2^nd Overall (S75) @DoktorFunk

 

The Reapers land at the bottom of the list, however they seem to be turning the tables this current season. The VHLM goes through waves, with teams going up and down as players graduate into the VHL. This data seems to be unfavorable to Philadelphia, who this upcoming draft have 4 players in the Top 12 ranked by total TPE. Maybe I’ll do this again in 5 seasons, and I think we could see the Reapers much higher on this list. Also, gives everyone a break from seeing Philly at the top of all the power rankings for this season.

 

T-10. Yukon Rush

TOTAL SCORE: 12

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 5

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 1

Waiver-signed Score: 1

Highest Drafted Player: Pistil Stamen, 1^st Overall (S75) @DMaximus

 

Wow, am I really going to write about every team like this? Seemed like a better idea in my head than in practice. Anyways, Yukon seems to have some good players in the 1^st round, but none that they actually signed. They are usually good for at least one 1^st rounder per year, so they definitely have that going for them. With recreates Pistil Stamen @DMaximus and Muffbeav @.sniffuM going last draft, they have a very solid 1^st gen defense pairing eligible for the next draft, in Kristof Welch @Juice and Germano Henchoz @RicoTheTrapGod. Hopefully we can see at least one of those factoring in here the next time I do this.

 

T-10. Ottawa Lynx

TOTAL SCORE: 12

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 4

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 0

Waiver-signed Score: 4

Highest Drafted Player: Ola Vikingstad, 3^rd Overall (S71) @Dil

 

Ottawa gets a little bit shafted in my research I think, adding the S70 draft would have possibly given them a couple more points on the board, with that amazing S71 season. Nonetheless, even sitting at 10^th here, they have still managed to produce a serviceable number of picks, on top a Founder’s Cup win. Very middling franchise however on my list, but they also seem to be the land of the recreates. Of their 4 first rounders, and 4 waiver signed player, only 1, a waiver signing, Zyrok12 @Zyrok, was a 1^st gen. Not a knock at all, just a funny point to look at.

 

T-8. Halifax 21^st

TOTAL SCORE: 13

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 3

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 2

Waiver-signed Score: 5

Highest Drafted Player: Dolant Fertitta, 10^th Overall (S75) @Dolant

 

Although Halifax’s highest drafted player is listed as 10^th, they have several waiver players who went on to become even higher picks, such as S73 1^st Overall pick Groovy Dood @bigAL. Even going 1 season in the 5 this data is based on with a record of 4-63-5, they have still managed to sit at a respectable 8^th place. Not much else I can think of to say about them, except they have a great logo and should never change their name. #WeTheFleet, or whatever.

 

T-8. Minnesota Storm 

TOTAL SCORE: 13

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 5

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 2

Waiver-signed Score: 1

Highest Drafted Player: Groovy Dood, 1^st Overall (S73) @bigAL

 

Most of Minny’s work is done in the S72 and S73 drafts, with all but one of their points being outside of those 2 drafts. Although I have a personal rivalry with the franchise as they beat my Marauders in the S73 Founder’s Cup finals, you must give them credit. @Rayzor_7 always seems to bring this franchise into the win column one way or another.  

 

T-6. Mississauga Hounds

TOTAL SCORE: 16

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 5

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 0

Waiver-signed Score: 6

Highest Drafted Player: Jacob Tonn (S73) @MexicanCow123 / L (S75) @gorlab T-4^th Overall 

 

Another hub for recreates, MIS has had all but a single point coming from recreated players. Not a knock on them at all! You also must give them credit for dealing with those L @gorlab and R @Kylrad guys, at least it gives them some clout in this article. One interesting tidbit, they had waiver signed all top 3 picks from the S71 draft, however, did not re-draft any of them, thus losing out on 6 potential points. Obviously beyond their control, which makes me think how I could have approached scoring differently.

 

T-6. Mexico City Kings

TOTAL SCORE: 16

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 3

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 2

Waiver-signed Score: 8

Highest Drafted Player: RJ Thatcher, 5^th Overall (S75) @jhatty8

 

One of the reasons I started this project is because I had a theory that LVA and MEX were 2 of the teams producing the highest number of new active members. Unfortunately, the way I have used the data has put Mexico in 6^th. Despite boasting the 3^rd most waiver signed players, the lack of 1^st round talent Mexico City has had in their draft years weighs them down. This is where I think my formula is lacking, since MEX is getting next to no credit for a bunch of players they could have completely introduced and gotten into the league.

 

5. Saskatoon Wild

TOTAL SCORE: 19

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 5

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 3

Waiver-signed Score: 6

Highest Drafted Player: Tyler Walker, 2^nd Overall (S73) @Advantage

 

Absolutely goated franchise, with future VHLM Hall of Famer Florent Vericel @dart now leading in all statistical categories for the club. In all seriousness, this team seems to never stop pumping out talent. 2^nd in the 1^st gen bonus category, they seem to have an eye for both new and old talent, as well as getting the most out of both. This is par for the course in the S76 draft, where they have Battre Sandstrom @Acydburn all but locked in to be a VHL 1^st round pick. Top this off with a S72 Founder’s Cup, and Sasky is sitting pretty at 5^th.

 

4. Miami Marauders

TOTAL SCORE: 28

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 8

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 6

Waiver-signed Score: 6

Highest Drafted Player: Cabe McJake, 7^th Overall (S75) @RedSus

 

Despite the first Miami Marauders players only appearing in the S73 VHL Draft as an expansion team, @Ricer13 has been a 1^st gen producing machine, with double the amount of VHL 1^st gens drafted in the first round than any other VHLM team. They started off with a bang, with 4 1^st rounders in their debut season. Truly a testament to the management style of the team, and a big reason as to why I am here writing this right now. @GustavMattiassuggested that I find a way to manipulate the data to put Miami on top, however I think 4 is well above expected, especially since they had 0 say in the first 2 drafts used in this data.

 

3. San Diego Marlins

TOTAL SCORE: 29

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 11

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 1

Waiver-signed Score: 6

Highest Drafted Player: Kyl Oferson, 1^st Overall (S71) @Nykonax

 

A surprise for me, since it seems like SDM is a team that doesn’t get a lot of praise. However, looking at the data, they have consistently been putting out top tier talent. Most of their points are coming from the S71 and S74 draft, in which they had 4 1^st rounders taken from their team in both years. They are also poised to have a strong S76 draft, in which they have 4 current players ranked in the top 9 by TPE. A 1^st rounder in all 5 years of the data analyzed, an impressive feat that only they and LVA hold.

 

2. Las Vegas Aces 

TOTAL SCORE: 33

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 10

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 2

Waiver-signed Score: 11

Highest Drafted Player: SS Hornet, 1^st Overall (S72) @McWolf

 

My prediction for the top team, turned out to just fall short. LVA hype seems to be in almost every VHL LR I am in, including general, and this team seems to never stop churning out these new players into VHL regulars. Just looking at my excel sheet for this article, LVA absolutely dominates the S72 draft with 4 picks in the top 11 and get 8 of their 11 waiver signing points from the S74 draft. Not much more to say about LVA, they are one of 2 teams to have a 1st round pick in every draft from S71 on. Maybe I'll say their logo is really cool so I can hit the word count? Hi @Spartan, needed to mention you somewhere to get the tag in.

 

1. Houston Bulls 

TOTAL SCORE: 36

Total VHL 1^st Rounders: 11

1^st Generation Player Bonus: 1

Waiver-signed Score: 13

Highest Drafted Player: Aloe Dear, 1^st Overall (S74) @Renomitsu

 

Finally, your number 1 team, the Houston Bulls. Tied for the most 1^st rounders, and 2 more waiver signed players than any other VHL team in the last 5 drafts. Their ranking is very heavily led by the S74 VHL draft, in which they had not 1, not 2, but 7 players picked in the first round. Pair that with the S72 draft, in which they had 5 waiver signed 1^st rounders, and it is easy to see why they are ranking here. Houston seems to be another team that is very good at attracting those re-creates, but I’m not exactly sure why. Hats off to RJ! @rjfryman

 

-----

 

Well, there you have it. Finally, I completed a media spot. As I was writing this I sort of got discouraged, as I realized my research wasn’t as fine tuned as I would have liked it to be. Also, it sort of just turned into my opinion on each VHLM team. Nonetheless, even if you ignore the rankings of the teams, it is still a good recap of how many players have been selected from each VHLM team in the S71-S75 timeline. If I were to do it again, I feel like I would need to add more research behind it. Teams should be rewarded for players they have brought into full-on activity, as well as players that have continued to be active for their entire career. Maybe I will think of something, maybe I will just claim this for 4 weeks and never think about it again. Only time will tell. If you would like to see the entire excel doc of where players were waiver-signed to and drafted from, just let me know. Thanks for reading my nonsense rambling!

 

Another footnote here, I’m just going off of which teams players were on in said season from the portal, which does not factor in if a player was traded. My apologies to any teams that suffered negative points from this.

 

2068 Words, claiming for 4 weeks starting with this week.

Edited December 6, 2020 by dlamb

[osens 297]

Meh

[hylands 845]

MEXICOOOOOOOOOOOO

[bigAL 2,176]

5 hours ago, dlamb said:

3. San Diego Marlins

TOTAL SCORE: 10

10 points ahead of 28 point MIA? rigged

 

But seriously holy hell this is great research and a great article coming from the research. Great job coming up with the methodology and sticking to it, even if it doesn't give you answers you like. It's always awesome when your hypotheses are challenged. I really like that you gave credit to waiver signings because that's a key part of the VHLM job. I'm surprised MIA isn't higher actually, but I bet a lot of the new gen talent there gets taken early 2nd round as a bit of a risky pick.

 

This is awesome. I'd tell you to keep it up but I know you'll multiclaim the shit outta this and we won't see anything new until 2021.

[dlamb 1,326]

2 hours ago, bigAL said:

10 points ahead of 28 point MIA? rigged

 

But seriously holy hell this is great research and a great article coming from the research. Great job coming up with the methodology and sticking to it, even if it doesn't give you answers you like. It's always awesome when your hypotheses are challenged. I really like that you gave credit to waiver signings because that's a key part of the VHLM job. I'm surprised MIA isn't higher actually, but I bet a lot of the new gen talent there gets taken early 2nd round as a bit of a risky pick.

 

This is awesome. I'd tell you to keep it up but I know you'll multiclaim the shit outta this and we won't see anything new until 2021.

Ah damn, was bound to make a mistake somewhere. Thank you for pointing that out! But I also agree, alot of 1st gens are probably taken in the 2nd round. I wanted to do more, this was just a lot of work already haha

[JigglyGumballs 1,056]

YOOO VEGAS

[Hex Universe 253]

Excellent article!

Although I do have a question

Say a VHLM team signs a player on waivers and then in that next off-season they get drafted away from that VHLM team to another VHLM team, but in the same off-season that player is also drafted in the First Round of VHL Draft. Which VHLM team would get the 2 points, the waiver team that the player has spent all of there time in up to that point, or their drafted team?

Edited December 7, 2020 by Hex Universe

[dlamb 1,326]

54 minutes ago, Hex Universe said:

Excellent article!

Although I do have a question

Say a VHLM team signs a player on waivers and then in that next off-season they get drafted away from that VHLM team to another VHLM team, but in the same off-season that player is also drafted in the First Round of VHL Draft. Which VHLM team would get the 2 points, the waiver team that the player has spent all of there time in up to that point, or their drafted team?

I believe that the drafted team, sadly enough, would get the 2 points. As stated in the article, I sort of mentioned this exact scenario. I need to think of a better way to award teams based on how they improved/impacted that players activity. 

Edited December 7, 2020 by dlamb

[dlamb 1,326]

Claim 2/4, week ending Dec 13

[dlamb 1,326]

Claim 3/4, week ending Dec 20

[dlamb 1,326]

Final Claim 4/4, week ending Dec 27